Tim de Silva, Stanford GSB: Insurance versus Moral Hazard in Income-Contingent Student Loan Repayment

Seminars - Department Seminar Series
Speakers
Tim de Silva, Stanford GSB
12:30pm - 1:45pm
Seminar Room 2-e4-sr03 - Via Roentgen, 1
Tim de Silva

ABSTRACT

Student loans with income-contingent repayment insure borrowers against income risk but can reduce their incentives to earn more. Using a change in Australia’s income-contingent repayment schedule, I show that borrowers reduce their labor supply to lower their repayments. These responses are larger among borrowers with more hourly flexibility, a lower probability of repayment, and tighter liquidity constraints. I use these responses to estimate a dynamic model of labor supply with frictions that generate imperfect adjustment. My estimates imply that the labor supply responses to income-contingent repayment limit the optimal amount of insurance in government-provided student loans. However, these responses are too small to justify fixed repayment contracts: restructuring outstanding student loans from fixed repayment to a constrained optimal income-contingent loan increases borrower welfare by the equivalent of a 1.3% increase in lifetime consumption at no additional fiscal cost.